Prison Street Pizza - Lahaina

Need a break from Maui's fresh seafood? Prison Street Pizza in Lahaina serves up jersey-style pizza, calzones, sub sandwiches and more - all perfected with over 40 years of testing and tasting! Prison Street Pizza brings delicious food to an old plantation-style house that was abandoned for nearly 20 years. They offer dine-in, pickup or carry out, so you can enjoy their comforting food wherever suits you best. This laid back atmosphere offers build your own pies and calzones with a selection of beer to complement your meal. 

Fresh Baked Calzone from Maui Pizzeria

Our Prison Street Pizza Favorites

  • Grandma's Pizza - This alfredo wonder will change your mind about what a pie should have on it! Chicken breast, spinach, garlic and mozzarella cheese top the pie on a saucy bed of alfredo. 
  • Build Your Own Calzone - The options are limitless: bacon, goat cheese, basil, mushroom, artichoke heart.... we could go on! Pick your favorite combo and dip in Marinara for a truly tasty experience. 
  • Classic Philly Sandwich - Probably a sandwich that needs no introduction, but certainly a round of applause. This classic Philly is topped off with provolone, green peppers and onions.